• 8 Best Murder Mystery Games UK 2022 | Talking Tables, Unsolved Case Files and More 1
  • 8 Best Murder Mystery Games UK 2022 | Talking Tables, Unsolved Case Files and More 2
  • 8 Best Murder Mystery Games UK 2022 | Talking Tables, Unsolved Case Files and More 3
  • 8 Best Murder Mystery Games UK 2022 | Talking Tables, Unsolved Case Files and More 4
  • 8 Best Murder Mystery Games UK 2022 | Talking Tables, Unsolved Case Files and More 5

8 Best Murder Mystery Games UK 2022 | Talking Tables, Unsolved Case Files and More

For an evening of fun with friends, you can’t beat a murder mystery party! Whether you fancy a murder themed dinner or a game night for your birthday or Halloween, these events are perfect for a group of friends as they get everyone involved with lots of acting and accusations (alcohol is optional!)

Brands like Paul Lamond, Cheatwell, and Red Herring Games have brought murder mystery party games into the mainstream; with sites likes Amazon and eBay offering some great options to choose from. If you’re hoping to host an Agatha Christie-style evening of suspicion and suspense at home, you can now buy a murder mystery in a box that comes with scripts, costume suggestions and everything else you could need. Deerstalkers at the ready.

This Article's Contributors

mybest Editing Team
  • Last updated: 04-04-2022
Table of Contents

How to Choose a Murder Mystery Game in the UK – Buying Guide

You could always just pick up the first murder mystery game box you see on the high street, but carefully planning the kind of game you and your friends would most enjoy actually helps you select a perfect murder mystery party you won’t forget for a while.

Choose the Setting of Your Murder Mystery Based On the Era or Location that Appeals to You Most

Choose the Setting of Your Murder Mystery Based On the Era or Location that Appeals to You Most
The setting of your murder mystery will dictate the theme for your whole evening, from costumes and characters to decorations and even food! Murder mystery party boxes are available with all kinds of different themes, from bygone eras to the present day and across all four corners of the globe.
If you love the glamour and nostalgia of Agatha Christie mysteries, you can pick a game set in the 1930s – perhaps in a stately countryside home, bustling London or even a luxury Egyptian hotel. More modern day options are murder mysteries that take place on TV and movie sets, sports events or in Michelin starred kitchens! Simply choose based on the aesthetic you like best.

Scripts or Improv? Choose According to Your Space, Guests’ Willingness to Act and if You’ll Serve Food

Murder mystery party games can either be performed from a fixed script which guests receive on the day, or are improvised according to more broader themes the players are given. Each type of game has its pros and cons but will definitely result in quite a different evening.

Murder Mysteries With a Fixed Script Work Well With a Sit-Down Dinner and Suit Guests Who Love to Perform

Murder Mysteries With a Fixed Script Work Well With a Sit-Down Dinner and Suit Guests Who Love to Perform
Murder Mystery party games with a fixed script are great fun if you enjoy a detailed, complicated murder plot and have friends who know each other or love to show off. This type of party is reliant on all guests being present, so works well for a small group who are all committed to coming.
Scripted mysteries also help everyone follow the plot more easily, allows space for discussion and can be structured around a dinner table with different courses served throughout the game. Murder Mysteries with a script are good for friendship groups who want to really get into character and are keen to actually solve the murder.
Some people do find scripts intimidating – if they are dyslexic or have English as a second language for instance – so keep those guests in mind when buying a scripted game.

Games which Encourage Improvisation Allow a Bit of Movement and Suit Guests of Different Acting Abilities

Games which Encourage Improvisation Allow a Bit of Movement and Suit Guests of Different Acting Abilities
The other type of murder mystery game has a looser plot and guests are asked to share their character’s story in their own words. This takes the spotlight off shy guests or anyone who doesn’t fancy reading out loud, but still allows wannabe actors to put on a show.
These games are free and fun, perfect to play around the house with nibbles and drinks, but the plot of the mystery can get lost (as can guests if you’re letting them roam free with a character card and a glass of wine!)

Some Murder Mysteries Come With a CD or DVD to Guide You – But it May Not be Necessary

Some Murder Mysteries Come With a CD or DVD to Guide You – But it May Not be Necessary
If you like the idea of a CD or DVD to really get you and your guests into the murder mystery spirit, then look out for game boxes that come with these included. This can be good for adding a bit of structure to the evening, keeping excitable guests focused and reminding everyone of the clues and information revealed at each point in the game.
The downside may be that you don’t have anywhere to play the audio or video, or it could be tough to gather up guests if you’ve had people milling about the house during each round. Depending on when and where you play it, this additional content can either add to or detract from the mysterious ambiance, so it’s worth thinking carefully about before you buy.

Menus and Costume Ideas Help With Scene Setting, Those Without offer More Impromptu ‘Whodunnits’

Menus and Costume Ideas Help With Scene Setting, Those Without offer More Impromptu ‘Whodunnits’
Choosing a murder mystery party game with costume and menu suggestions is a big commitment, but so much fun! Guests are given character descriptions and costume ideas while hosts get tips on decor and even advice on what food to serve after each round of the game. Depending on your hosting style and your group of friends this can be fantastic, but of course takes lots of organisation.
On the other hand, there are murder mystery games which can be played a little more off-the-cuff; closer to a board game than a role-playing improvisation session. These games are an excellent choice if your friendship circle is a little less flamboyant and simply prefer to puzzle out who was the murderer without putting on a questionable accent or a silly hat.

Murder Mysteries With Variable Outcomes Can Be Played Again; Games With Fixed Scenarios Can’t

Murder Mysteries With Variable Outcomes Can Be Played Again; Games With Fixed Scenarios Can’t
Another point worth keeping in mind is that some murder mysteries can be played a few times, with the murderer being chosen at random at the start of the game. This is good if you want a bit more mystery for your money, and want to recycle the game with different parts of your social group.
Mysteries which have only one solution tend to be more detailed and will have a fixed script rather than improvisation and although they can only be used once, the benefit is they will usually create a more complex mystery plot which is a bit more fun to mull over and solve.

Check the Age Range the Game is Suited to and Pick Your Murder Mystery According to Who’s Coming

Check the Age Range the Game is Suited to and Pick Your Murder Mystery According to Who’s Coming
One last point to think about is the age range of the guests. Some murder mystery parties contain themes that are best suited to adults over 18, while others are perfect for younger detectives. Check the box to see what kind of theme the murder mystery has and who it’s deemed appropriate for before investing.
For “murder” mystery games, the youngest age recommendation is usually 13 plus, but it’s up to you whether you want to play it with any younger children. Keep in mind that there are other kinds of mystery party games available for kids online.

The Best Murder Mystery Games in the UK

Next, it’s time to introduce the best murder mystery box sets you can buy this year. There should be something for everyone, at great value prices too, so take a look and see which game best suits the party you have in mind.

8

BV LeisureMurder in the Thirties

£12.95

Setting1930s living room
Number of Players8
TypeScripted
CD/DVD IncludedYes
Menu/Costume SuggestionsYes
Re-UsableNo
Age Range18 +
7

Murder Mystery Flexi Party Murder at the Disco

£20.00

Setting1977 New York, Disco 54 nightclub
Number of Players6 – 14
TypeImprovised
CD/DVD IncludedNo
Menu/Costume SuggestionsCostumes only
Re-UsableNo
Age Range18 +
6

Cheatwell GamesHost Your Own Murder Mystery – The Porthole Affair

£12.99

Setting1935, the RMS Olympic, bound for New York
Number of Players8
TypeScripted
CD/DVD IncludedYes
Menu/Costume SuggestionsYes
Re-UsableNo
Age Range16 +
5

Culinario Mortale Recipe for Death

£19.95

SettingA restaurant in the Scottish Highlands
Number of Players5 – 7
TypeImprovised
CD/DVD IncludedNo
Menu/Costume SuggestionsNo
Re-UsableNo
Age Range16 +
4

Ace Murder Mystery Parties A Case of Treasure and Treachery

£26.99

Setting1776, Port Royal, Jamaica
Number of Players8 – 10
TypeScripted
CD/DVD IncludedYes
Menu/Costume SuggestionsCostume only
Re-UsableNo
Age Range14 +
3

Unsolved Case FilesBanks, Jamie - Cold Case Murder Mystery

£29.29

Setting1990s/today, East Verona High School
Number of Players1 +
TypeScripted
CD/DVD IncludedNo (internet required)
Menu/Costume SuggestionsNo
Re-UsableNo
Age Range13 +
2

Talking Tables Host Your Own Murder Mystery Night

£30.34

Setting1920s, at the Full House Theatre
Number of PlayersUp to 12
TypeImprovised
CD/DVD IncludedNo
Menu/Costume SuggestionsCostume only
Re-UsableYes – 3 possible outcomes
Age Range13 +
1

Inspector McClueDeath by Chocolate

£12.94

Setting1900, Paris
Number of Players6 -8
TypeScripted
CD/DVD IncludedYes
Menu/Costume SuggestionsYes
Re-UsableNo
Age Range13 +

Compare the Best Murder Mystery Games

Image
1
Inspector McClue Death by Chocolate 1

Inspector McClue

2
Talking Tables  Host Your Own Murder Mystery Night 1

Talking Tables

3
Unsolved Case Files Banks, Jamie - Cold Case Murder Mystery 1

Unsolved Case Files

4
Ace Murder Mystery Parties  A Case of Treasure and Treachery 1

Ace Murder Mystery Parties

5
Culinario Mortale  Recipe for Death 1

Culinario Mortale

6
Cheatwell Games Host Your Own Murder Mystery – The Porthole Affair 1

Cheatwell Games

7
Murder Mystery Flexi Party  Murder at the Disco 1

Murder Mystery Flexi Party

8
BV Leisure Murder in the Thirties 1

BV Leisure

Name

Death by Chocolate

Host Your Own Murder Mystery Night

Banks, Jamie - Cold Case Murder Mystery

A Case of Treasure and Treachery

Recipe for Death

Host Your Own Murder Mystery – The Porthole Affair

Murder at the Disco

Murder in the Thirties

Features

A Fun-Packed Night of Crime, Clues and Conjecture

Beautiful, Simple and Fun

Who Really Killed Jamie Banks

Detailed Game With a Pirate Twist

If You’ve a Taste for Murder

Murder at Sea

Death on the Dancefloor

Who Shot Sam Shady?

Price£12.94£30.34£29.29£26.99£19.95£12.99£20.00£12.95
Setting1900, Paris1920s, at the Full House Theatre1990s/today, East Verona High School 1776, Port Royal, JamaicaA restaurant in the Scottish Highlands1935, the RMS Olympic, bound for New York1977 New York, Disco 54 nightclub1930s living room
Number of Players6 -8Up to 121 +8 – 105 – 786 – 148
TypeScriptedImprovisedScriptedScriptedImprovisedScriptedImprovisedScripted
CD/DVD IncludedYesNoNo (internet required)YesNoYesNoYes
Menu/Costume SuggestionsYesCostume onlyNoCostume onlyNoYesCostumes onlyYes
Re-UsableNoYes – 3 possible outcomesNoNoNoNoNoNo
Age Range13 +13 +13 +14 +16 +16 +18 +18 +
Link

Things Are About to Get Dicey

Things Are About to Get Dicey

Do you find that you have nothing to do but watch the same TV shows on a Saturday evening? Well, we have just the remedy to get you out of that rut! We have a selection of fabulously fun and slightly cheeky games for you to play or fight over with your family; take a look.

Summary

And that concludes our guide to buying the most exciting and suspenseful murder mystery game for you and your friends. We hope at least one of our suggestions will inspire you to invite the gang round for some sleuthing and interrogating in the living room!
From laid-back parties to intense feats of acting, from games with scripts to ones where you’re free to improvise, there’s something for everyone on our list. All that’s left to do is don your costume, get into character and prepare for an evening of laughter, lies and tracking down who on Earth dunnit!

Author: Annie Hopkins

Related Posts

  • Top 10 Best JRPGs for PS4 in the UK 2021 (Final Fantasy, Dragon Quest and More)
    Top 10 Best JRPGs for PS4 in the UK 2021 (Final Fantasy, Dragon Quest and More)
    JRPGs, or Japanese role-playing games, are a staple of the RPG genre that has been around since the 1980s. Sony’s PlayStation remains a go-to console for Japanese RPG developers for its cutting-edge graphics and easy to use controls, with the PS4 boasting some of the highest acclaimed titles from Square Enix, Atlus, Sega and many more.Our buying guide is here to help newbies know where to start and showcase some excellent titles JRPG veterans may have missed. From Final Fantasy to Dragon Quest, in this article, we share with you our ranking of the top 10 JRPGs for the PS4. Read on for tips on what you should look for when shopping online on Amazon, Argos and eBay.
    Games
  • 10 Best Nintendo Switch Accessories UK 2022 | Switch Pro Controller, Power Banks and More
    10 Best Nintendo Switch Accessories UK 2022 | Switch Pro Controller, Power Banks and More
    The Nintendo Switch is the most versatile console on the market at the moment, being both a home entertainment system and a portable handheld. It is also currently the most popular, having sold over 90 million units worldwide. This massive popularity combined with the adaptability of the console has resulted in a plethora of various accessories, some of which are even tailor-made for specific games.There’s no doubt that the Switch, the Switch Lite and the new OLED model are fantastic consoles in their own right, but picking up a few accessories can make playing favourites like Mario Kart, Super Smash Bros and Pokémon even more fun. From cases and covers to Joy-Cons holders and bundles, we're here to guide you through the best accessories and show you where to find them on Amazon, Argos and more. 
    Games
  • 10 Best Video Games for Kids UK 2022 | Super Mario 3D World, Minecraft and More
    10 Best Video Games for Kids UK 2022 | Super Mario 3D World, Minecraft and More
    Buying a video game for a child can be a tricky proposition. In the modern world, many kids already know about video games, but the most popular titles aren't always the most suitable. So how do you know which games are appropriate for kids?In this article, we share the 10 best child-friendly games on console and PC available to buy online in the UK on Amazon, Argos and various gaming platforms. So whether you're looking for world-building creativity, a computer-based puzzle game that's suitable for a 7 year old, or the top titles on the Nintendo Switch, in this article we show you how to choose!
    Games
  • 10 Best Cooperative Board Games UK 2022 Guide
    10 Best Cooperative Board Games UK 2022 Guide
    Board games are more popular now than ever before, with experts predicting that the global industry will be worth more than £9 billion by 2023. While many people think of board games as something that causes family arguments over the holidays, there are a number of great collaborative variations on the market that promote working and winning together.If you’re not a fan of board games because you seem to find yourself losing to a friend or sibling, take a look at our selection of the best cooperative games to buy on Amazon and John Lewis. We've included plenty of options for 2 players, families and beginners from some of the most well-known names in the industry like Fantasy Flight Games, Cephalofair Games and Z-man Games. 
    Games
  • 10 Best Legacy Board Games UK 2022 | Betrayal, Machi Koro and More
    10 Best Legacy Board Games UK 2022 | Betrayal, Machi Koro and More
    Legacy board games take you and your group on a unique and competitive experience with an ever-changing game that spans multiple campaign-style rounds. Although it feels rather unconventional, you will find yourself destroying game elements, tearing cards to pieces and adding stickers to your board on your path to success. The most cooperative games leave you with a distinctive end-game board unlike any other player's. Whether you are looking for a game for 2 players, 5 players, 6 players, couples or families, you're in the right place. We've ranked a list of the best Legacy board games from Amazon, including legacy classics such as Betrayal Legacy, the Pandemic Legacy Board Game and Ultimate Werewolf Legacy, to get you started on your game as soon as possible. 
    Games
  • 10 Best Indie Games on Switch UK 2022 | Hollow Night, Stardew Valley and More
    10 Best Indie Games on Switch UK 2022 | Hollow Night, Stardew Valley and More
    We all know that the Nintendo Switch is home to titles like Pokémon, the Legend of Zelda and Mario Kart, but it's also become something of an industry leader when it comes to indie games. There are plenty of hidden gems featuring characters that aren't as instantly recognisable as Mario or Pikachu, but we can assure you that you'll still have plenty of fun.Luckily, even the top indie games are also considerably cheaper than first-party titles, so you won't have to break the bank to try them. Whether you're a fan of action-packed platformers, immersive exploration or a relaxing farming experience, we've found the best indie games on the Nintendo Switch available online on Amazon, eBay and Argos for you to check out from the comfort of your sofa. 
    Games
  • 10 Best Black Friday Nintendo Switch Deals UK 2022 | Nintendo, Ubisoft, SanDisk and More
    10 Best Black Friday Nintendo Switch Deals UK 2022 | Nintendo, Ubisoft, SanDisk and More
    It's now nearly five years since the Switch's original release, and the hybrid console continues to sell like hotcakes. Nintendo has since introduced the extra portable Switch Lite to their roster and, more recently, the OLED model, which offers crisp graphics and bold colours on its updated screen. If you're on the fence about buying a Switch, this Black Friday could be the perfect time to get your hands on the console while saving yourself a bit of money.There are now tons of Amazon Black Friday deals to choose from, and they vary wildly, from the incredible to the borderline offensive. Taking the Switch's recently reduced RRP into account, we're here to give you an honest rundown of the top 10 best Black Friday Nintendo Switch offers currently available in the UK, including Joy-Cons and bundles with games and accessories.
    Games
  • 10 Best Simulator Games UK 2022 Guide | Top Picks Include: Surviving Mars, Football Manager and More
    10 Best Simulator Games UK 2022 Guide | Top Picks Include: Surviving Mars, Football Manager and More
    Simulator games have had a popularity boom in recent years with everything from realistic lifestyle simulators to absurd and adventurous space age fantasies. This boom in the market is great for gamers who want to consume as much simulator content as possible, but it does mean you have to sift through masses of poor quality games in order to find a gem. But we're about to solve that problem for you!In this article, we have compiled a list of the top 10 simulator games currently available in the UK. We have curated some helpful information about average playtime, age ratings and buying options. Plus, we have included games on Xbox, PlayStation, PC, SteamOS, and Mac, so no matter how you choose to play, you'll be sure to find a game to suit you.
    Games
  • 10 Best FPS Games UK 2022 | Call of Duty, Halo and More
    10 Best FPS Games UK 2022 | Call of Duty, Halo and More
    The FPS, or first-person shooter, has consistently remained one of the most popular gaming genres. While many titles can look similar at first glance, the gameplay style varies drastically from title to title as FPS games can be both high-octane, reaction-based thrill rides and slow, methodical tactical shooters. From cooperative adventure-based games to competitive online titles, we've picked the best FPS games available online for all the major platforms, including PlayStation, Xbox, and Nintendo Switch, from publishers like Electronic Arts, Activision, and Microsoft. Whether you're looking for a fast and fun hero-based team game, military simulation, or a looter shooter, we've ranked the 10 best FPS games in the UK!
    Games
  • 10 Best Card Games for Kids UK 2022 | Top Trumps, Pokémon and More
    10 Best Card Games for Kids UK 2022 | Top Trumps, Pokémon and More
    In the age of video games, card games have been a little bit forgotten, but they're still an excellent way of getting the kids together for some no-screen fun. They're great for bringing out on a rainy day and perfect for whiling away the hours on long road trips. From competitive strategy games to humourous party games, there really is a kids' card game for everyone - even the grownups!However, the need to check age recommendations and rules of play means that shopping for card games for kids is time-consuming. That's why we're here to help with a buying guide that'll walk you through everything you need to know and a top 10 list of the best card games for kids. With our buying guide at your disposal, shopping for a kids' card game will take minutes rather than hours!
    Games
  • Popular Posts

  • 10 Best Desk Toys UK 2022 | Newton's Cradle, Rubik's Cube and More
    10 Best Desk Toys UK 2022 | Newton's Cradle, Rubik's Cube and More
    Long day at the office? Desk toys are a great way to inject some fun into your working day as well as help pass the time and relieve stress. These usually come in the form of novelty and compact items that are perfect for adults and office workers' desks. Although Newton's Cradle was the original desktop toy, puzzles and arcade games have also risen in popularity in recent years. With a wide range of educational, fun, and challenging toys to choose from, it can be hard to know which one is the best for you. This buying guide will go through everything you need to know to help you decide. We've also included a list of the ten best desk toys available from Amazon UK, including ball games, kinetic toys, magnetic toys, and one's that showcase the laws of physics and science. 
    Games
  • 10 Best Video Games for Kids UK 2022 | Super Mario 3D World, Minecraft and More
    10 Best Video Games for Kids UK 2022 | Super Mario 3D World, Minecraft and More
    Buying a video game for a child can be a tricky proposition. In the modern world, many kids already know about video games, but the most popular titles aren't always the most suitable. So how do you know which games are appropriate for kids?In this article, we share the 10 best child-friendly games on console and PC available to buy online in the UK on Amazon, Argos and various gaming platforms. So whether you're looking for world-building creativity, a computer-based puzzle game that's suitable for a 7 year old, or the top titles on the Nintendo Switch, in this article we show you how to choose!
    Games
  • 10 Best Escape Room Board Games 2022 | UK Gaming Blogger Reviewed
    10 Best Escape Room Board Games 2022 | UK Gaming Blogger Reviewed
    It’s hard to have missed the increasingly popular rise of escape rooms which have seemed to have popped up in every city and town across the UK. However, one slightly lesser-known concept is the tabletop escape room in a box, which allows you the convenience and comfort of playing from home whilst putting your brains to the test with entertaining gameplay.To help you decide, we've ranked the best escape room board games to buy from Amazon and Argos with picks from Mattel as well as the ever-popular Exit: The Game and Unlock! series. Moreover, we have partnered with video game blogger Benjamin Titmus for reviewing and fact-checking the article so that we can deliver you the best information.
    Games
  • 10 Best Party Games 2022 | UK Gaming Blogger Reviewed
    10 Best Party Games 2022 | UK Gaming Blogger Reviewed
    Whether you're hosting a quiet night indoors with friends, a wild birthday shindig, a hen or stag night or an outside garden family BBQ, choosing the best party game can make your night one to remember. Do you plump for a challenging mental board game, something a little more physical, a funny card game, or a drink-orientated activity to loosen the guests up? Perhaps kids are attending, and you want to cater for all ages, from 3-year-olds to teenagers. We're here to help, so we've put together a buying guide to answer all your questions. Plus, we've chosen our top 10 party games to buy online at Amazon, Argos and John Lewis. Moreover, we have partnered with video game blogger Benjamin Titmus for reviewing and fact-checking the article so that we can deliver you the best information.
    Games
  • 10 Best Horror Games for PS4 2022 | UK Gaming Blogger Reviewed
    10 Best Horror Games for PS4 2022 | UK Gaming Blogger Reviewed
    If you're a fan of the frightening, savour the supernatural or you're simply mad about the macabre, horror games are an interactive and immersive way to scare yourself silly! This article will help you get your virtual chills and thrills with the best horror games for PS4 to buy online. Before you spend too much time sifting through spoiler-ridden reviews, check out our selection of 10 blood-curdling classics for PlayStation 4. You'll find VR exclusives, FPS, multiplayer, 2-player, action, survival and sci-fi themed games on our list, all of which are available from Amazon. Read on, if you dare, for our guide on how to find the creepiest console games ― they're guaranteed to make the hairs stand up on the back of your neck! Moreover, we have partnered with video game blogger Benjamin Titmus for reviewing and fact-checking the article so that we can deliver you the best information.
    Games
  • 10 Best Video Games With Female Protagonists UK 2022 | Horizon Zero Dawn, Tomb Raider and More
    10 Best Video Games With Female Protagonists UK 2022 | Horizon Zero Dawn, Tomb Raider and More
    Inclusivity is an important issue across the world – and that’s no different with video gaming. Developers, writers and designers are working harder for equal representation with more female lead characters at the forefront of not just indie games but AAA, high-budget games as well. It doesn’t matter if you own a Sony PlayStation, a Microsoft Xbox, a Nintendo Switch or a PC, there are many strong female figures for you to team up with through epic adventures. In this article, we'll take you through genre, gameplay time and other considerations and recommend our top ten picks for you to order from Amazon, Argos and eBay. 
    Games
  • 10 Best Card Games for Kids UK 2022 | Top Trumps, Pokémon and More
    10 Best Card Games for Kids UK 2022 | Top Trumps, Pokémon and More
    In the age of video games, card games have been a little bit forgotten, but they're still an excellent way of getting the kids together for some no-screen fun. They're great for bringing out on a rainy day and perfect for whiling away the hours on long road trips. From competitive strategy games to humourous party games, there really is a kids' card game for everyone - even the grownups!However, the need to check age recommendations and rules of play means that shopping for card games for kids is time-consuming. That's why we're here to help with a buying guide that'll walk you through everything you need to know and a top 10 list of the best card games for kids. With our buying guide at your disposal, shopping for a kids' card game will take minutes rather than hours!
    Games
  • Popular Item Lists

    Search by Category