Automotive
Baby Products
Beauty
Books
Business, Industry & Science
Computers & Accessories
DIY, Garden & Tools
Electronics & Photo
Fashion
Grocery
Health & Personal Care
Home & Kitchen
Large Appliances
Musical Instruments & DJ
PC & Video Games
Pet Supplies
Sports & Outdoors
Stationery & Office Products
Toys & Games
Household goods
PC and cameras
Home appliances and electronics
Cosmetics and skincare
Health
Food and drinks
Kitchen supplies
Clothing
Shoes
Accessories
Kids and baby
Interior and furniture
Hobbies
Outdoor
DIY and tools
Sports and fitness
Pets
Books, CDs, DVDs
Games
Cars and motorcycles
Gifts
Housing equipment and renovation
Travel
Smartphones and mobile phones
Music
Smartphone applications
If you've decided to try your hand at baking, you'll be looking for a baking tray that's durable, non-stick, easy to clean, and effectively designed. To lend a hand, our guide explains how to choose your ideal oven tray, whether you want to make biscuits or brownies, roast vegetables, prepare Yorkshire puddings or cook the perfect pizza.
Across home stores like John Lewis and eCommerce leaders Amazon and eBay, our countdown rates and reviews the best enamel, glass and metal baking trays from brands such as Le Creuset and KitchenCraft, all according to function, quality, and affordable prices. On your marks, get set, bake!
A recommendation service that carefully researches each product and consults with experts across many disciplines. We are constantly creating new content to provide the best shopping experience from choosing ‘cosmetics’ to ‘food and drink’, ‘home appliances’ to ‘kids and baby’ products, reaching users all across the United Kingdom.
Table of Contents
In order to choose the best possible baking tray, think about the types of projects you have planned and look at the different qualities each one has – whether that's factors that affect storage, cleaning, or the bakes you're creating.
Firstly, think about the type of baking you're hoping to do, and if you require something for a variety of purposes or just one. For cookies and biscuits, as well as roasting meat and veg, heating ready-meals or baking a potato, a completely flat tray will do just fine.
For muffins and tarts, choose a tray divided into 8, 10 or 12 separate sections as you prefer, and for Yorkshire puddings a baking tray with 4 large holes is ideal. Round trays make the perfect base to cook a pizza, especially if you like to make your own.
Deeper dish trays can be good for simple one-dish bakes like mixed veggies, pasta bakes, or pies, though be aware that they aren't as useful for cookies or similar as the high sides can make your items difficult to remove.
Don't forget to look out for a baking tray which is the right fit for your oven, and optionally, your dishwasher too.
Larger trays measuring between 30 and 40 cm are brilliant for lovely oozing cookies or greater quantities in general, but won't fit into smaller ovens. Choose a baking tray with a length of around 25 cm if you have a cosy kitchen with a smaller sized oven, or to be completely safe, get the measuring tape out!
Next, materials. There are a few different options to choose from when it comes to baking trays, and they all have certain qualities or disadvantages that we'll go into.
Carbon steel baking trays are very common and have the benefit of being naturally non-stick. They also conduct heat brilliantly and are exceptionally hard and strong, meaning they can withstand years of use and the roughest of washing up sessions.
Aluminium trays are a less costly metal option, but they do have a tendency to react to acidic foods which can end up adopting a slightly metallic flavour once cooked.
Ceramic-coated trays are superbly speedy to clean and your food will categorically never end up tasting like metal. They're also best for a clean relocation of your bake from tray to plate.
And finally, non-stick borosilicate glass trays (such as those made by the household brand Pyrex) are a stand-out choice as they absorb and retain heat spectacularly and are really easy to clean.
Whether or not each material is dishwasher- or microwave-safe can vary between brands, but is worth checking if you'd like these benefits.
For super-easy cleaning and removal of your bakes, as well as a tray that stays shiny and new for longer, look out for those with a non-stick coating.
As mentioned above, carbon steel and glass are said to be naturally non-stick as ingredients do not cling to the surface, especially with a layer of oil or butter. You also won't have to be as careful when using metal implements or scourers.
However, if you prefer grease-free cooking (for health reasons or taste preferences) you may want to look out for a baking tray that's been especially treated with a coating such as Teflon or fluoropolymer – just remember to care for and clean it gently.
Products | Image | Click to purchase | Price | Key features | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Pyrex Baking Tray | £11.99 Low Mid | High-Quality, Scratch-Resistant Tray for Uniform Cooking | ||
2 | Le Creuset Non-Stick 12 Cup Muffin Tray | £22.95 High Mid | Best for Muffins and Other Multiple Mini Makes | ||
3 | MasterClass Smart Ceramic Baking Tray | £14.49 Mid | Easy-Clean Copper Finish Tray for Grease-Free Cooking | ||
4 | Le Creuset Non-Stick Baking Tray | £27.20 High | Award-Winning Heavy-Duty Tray With Added Grip | ||
5 | KitchenCraft Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Brownie Tin | £19.94 High Mid | The Clever Way to Professional-Style Brownies | ||
6 | Circulon Momentum Large Oven Tray | £14.00 Mid | Large and Sturdy With a Three-Layer Non-Stick Coating | ||
7 | Eaziglide Neverstick2 Non-Stick Baking Tray | £22.00 High Mid | A Toughened Tray Which Cooks Evenly and Won't Stick | ||
8 | Samuel Groves 4 Cup Yorkshire Pudding Tray|Pack of 2 | £9.99 Low Mid | The Best Non-Stick Pan for Your Sunday Yorkshires | ||
9 | John Lewis & Partners Classic Pizza Tray | £8.00 Low | Carbon Steel Round Tray for a Flawless Pizza Base | ||
10 | Barmans Rustic Baking Tray | £18.44 Mid | Ideal for One-Tray Veg Roasting or the Perfect Pie |
Our winner is this tray from trusty Pyrex, the reliable material of which ensures your bake is cooked perfectly without imparting flavour. Alongside this, it boasts an impressive size and durability, and is suitable for use in the microwave, dishwasher, and freezer.
Crafted from borosilicate glass and non-stick by nature, this tray also helps you avoid losing half your bakes when they refuse to be pried onto a plate! Totally appropriate for all manner of baking and roasting, you can use any utensil without fear of scratching, too.
Our pick for the best muffin tray is this top-quality tin from Le Creuset, with 12 identical spaces in which to pour your mixture (after treating yourself to a lick of the spoon, of course). It's non-stick too, so you can even forego the paper cases.
A particular plus is that the cups have a great depth, making them brilliantly suited to all kinds of bakes, from sweet or savoury muffins to jam tarts and even bread rolls. Formed from carbon steel, this tray won't lose its shape even under the highest temperatures, and also features silicone easy-grip handles.
Aside from its contemporary looks, the biggest bonus of this particular baking tray is its combination of a non-stick coating and a grid-pattern design, which together prevent your cookies from clinging to its surface post-oven and cut out the need to always have greaseproof on hand.
Oven safe up to 240 degrees, this tray is suited not only to sweet bakes but also the roasting of meat and vegetables, along with re-heating your pre-cooked favourites. It even has a 25 year guarantee!
Add this compact, square tray to your kitchen collection for many happy years of baking. Super simple to slide in and out of your cooker, the weighty carbon steel cooks evenly and is ideal for a wide variety of bakes including scones and meringues.
Used either alone or in unison with your own cake rings or shape moulds, this durable tray has a non-stick coating that means it's easy to clean and will resist scratching from metal utensils. Best of all, the heat-resilient silicone strips mean it's easy to grip without the fear of dropping it!
For scrumptious brownies with crispy edges and syrupy centres, try this clever baking tray with dividers. It makes 18 neatly-cut treats that can be cleanly removed, with no sticky crumbs and no uneven pieces.
When your bake is ready, simply raise the metal divider and you'll be left with smartly-spaced brownies, cooked to perfection! The fact it is crafted from carbon steel means it'll heat well across all of your brownies, blondies, or cake slices, and will last well across the years.
This spacious baking tray has a low rim with easy-to-grip handles on either side and a grooved design which prevents sticking, in addition to three layers of ultra-smooth non-stick coating. This being said, some reviews did complain that the non-stick didn't last as long as they would've liked.
Made from sturdy carbon steel, this tray promises not to buckle under temperatures up to 230 degrees. Plus, its pattern and build are designed to evenly distribute heat so you're left with a plate of identically baked snacks every time.
Suitable for many a baking need, this medium-sized tray features a superb non-stick coating, so you can skip the greasing stage and make healthier bakes. It can then be comfortably wiped clean and popped in the dishwasher after use.
Using toughened aluminium – which makes it suitable for intense heats in the oven – the Eaziglide tray evenly distributes heat to ensure your food is nicely cooked through. The speckled design is quite stylish too! It doesn't have any built-in handles, though, so be careful when carrying it.
To bake your most magnificent Yorkshire puddings yet, this tray with a smooth non-stick coating is a superb pick. It has holes for four huge, fluffy Yorkies and comes as a pack of 2, so you'll be able to make enough for everyone.
Safe to clean in your dishwasher and for freezing too if you need, this small tray may not be as versatile as some others on our list, but is a practical essential for all Sunday roast aficionados!
This wide circular pizza tray has a pattern of tiny holes which allow heat and air to reach your pizza base, allowing it to rise beautifully and cook evenly. The non-stick covering also means no tricky scraping or poorly-bound pizza.
With a diameter of 30 centimetres, this tray allows you to create a lovely big pizza in the comfort of your own home. Unfortunately it's no good for cleaning in your dishwasher, but the coating should keep things simple.
This gorgeous enamel tray is not covered with a non-stick coating, but what it lacks in this department, it makes up for in aesthetic beauty. A boon for amateur chefs who love one-tray cooking!
The simple blue rim on a white background makes a stylish addition to a minimalist kitchen, not to mention it also cleans up well in your dishwasher. Though, it is pretty big, measuring in at 38 cm, so will only suit larger ovens.
Can't wait to start cooking with your new baking tray? Here is a simple recipe for peanut butter cookies that only uses three main ingredients!
The ingredients are:
Here's the recipe:
Want more ways to channel your inner Mary Berry and whip up sugary delights even Nigella would lust after? We have plenty of articles which will inspire you to live your best baking life, from chocolatey ingredients to essential kitchen tools. Click the links below to explore some confection-themed corkers!
No. 1: Pyrex|Baking Tray
No. 2: Le Creuset|Non-Stick 12 Cup Muffin Tray
No. 3: MasterClass |Smart Ceramic Baking Tray
No. 4: Le Creuset|Non-Stick Baking Tray
No. 5: KitchenCraft|Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Brownie Tin
View Full RankingThe descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
Automotive
Baby Products
Beauty
Books
Business, Industry & Science
Computers & Accessories
DIY, Garden & Tools
Electronics & Photo
Fashion
Grocery
Health & Personal Care
Home & Kitchen
Large Appliances
Musical Instruments & DJ
PC & Video Games
Pet Supplies
Sports & Outdoors
Stationery & Office Products
Toys & Games
Household goods
PC and cameras
Home appliances and electronics
Cosmetics and skincare
Health
Food and drinks
Kitchen supplies
Clothing
Shoes
Accessories
Kids and baby
Interior and furniture
Hobbies
Outdoor
DIY and tools
Sports and fitness
Pets
Books, CDs, DVDs
Games
Cars and motorcycles
Gifts
Housing equipment and renovation
Travel
Smartphones and mobile phones
Music
Smartphone applications